Scarborough Shoal lost to China says Philippines spokesman

Scarborough Shoal lost to China says Philippines spokesman
Online English lessons

Filipinos finally heard last Sunday (April 14) what many have dreaded hearing for sometime. Scarborough Shoal has been lost to China.

In March 2016 these plans purported to show Chinese plans for Scarborough Shoal – Huangyan (Yellow Rock) – Island appeared on a Chinese military enthusiast website
In March 2016 this image claiming to show Chinese development plans for Scarborough Shoal – Huangyan (Yellow Rock) – Island appeared on a Chinese military enthusiast website Image: Courtesy The Washington Free Beacon

The candid and perhaps unintentional admission, largely overlooked by the Philippine media, first came during a fiery exchange between former foreign affairs secretary Albert del Rosario and Philippine Presidential spokesperson Salvador F Panelo, and were repeated today, April 18.

The comments are the first yet by a senior Philippine government representative that the country no longer exerts control over Scarborough Shoal.

In response to reports of Chinese fishing vessels ‘swarming’ Panatag Shoal (Tagalog: Kulumpol ng Panatag), Mr del Rosario on Saturday urged President Rodrigo Duterte to implement the 2016 arbitral ruling in favour of the Philippines against China over the territorial dispute in the South China Sea (West Philippine Sea).

“What is currently notable is that Beijing is now clearly revisiting its excessive and unlawful claim in the South China Sea that has been ruled upon by the arbitral tribunal, which ruling is now an integral part of international law”, Mr del Rosario said in a statement

Albert del Rosario led the charge against China's claim to Scarborough Shoal when he was Philippine foreign minister
Albert del Rosario led the charge against China’s claim to Scarborough Shoal when he was Philippine foreign minister (File 2014) U.S. Marine Corps Forces, Pacific/ Sgt. Isis Ramirez

As foreign minister Mr del Rosario was responsible for the filing and representations before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in The Hague against China’s claim to resources inside its so-called Nine-Dash Line, in particular Scarborough shoal.

In July 2016 the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) dismissed China’s claim.

Last month Mr del Rosario and former Ombudsman Conchita Carpio-Morales, filed a case against Chinese President Xi Jinping in the International Criminal Court (ICC) in The Hague. The complaint alledges crimes against humanity and “massive” environmental destruction by China in connection with its activities to gain control in the South China Sea.

Palace: It’s your fault we lost Scarborough

The call on Saturday earned a withering response from Mr Panelo, who on Sunday said: “Mr del Rosario, being responsible for the loss of the country’s possession of the Scarborough Shoal during his stint as Foreign Affairs Secretary by naively causing the withdrawal of our armed ship in the area of conflict, certainly can not put forward his pretended patriotism and feigned righteousness as if he has not contributed vastly to the unwelcome situation we are presently in”.

On Wednesday the war of words continued, with Mr del Rosario describing Mr Panelo as “mindless”, adding that he “appears to be in surrender without lifting a finger to peacefully defend what is ours”.

Today Mr Panelo ramped up the attack on Mr del Rosario, repeating his claim from Sunday, adding Beijing has had “de facto control over the [Scarborough Shoal] shoal off Zambales province for seven years now”.

The Philippines lost Scarborough Shoal due to Mr del Rosario’s “horrendous mistake. We are now trying to fix his mess, and no amount of justification from him could justify his monumental blunder”, Mr Panelo said.

Salvador Panelo: The Philippines lost Scarborough Shoal due to Mr del Rosario’s “horrendous mistake
Salvador Panelo: The Philippines lost Scarborough Shoal due to Mr del Rosario’s “horrendous mistake Office of the Presidential Spokesperson

Insisting that there was no shelving of the arbitral ruling, Mr Panelo said President Duterte believes that the best way to resolve the maritime dispute is through “peaceful and diplomatic negotiations with China.  “Armed acts of enforcement” may result in a bloody war to the detriment of the Philippines, he said.

Two weeks ago Manila protested what it described as the presence of “hundreds of Chinese vessels swarming around Pag-asa Island”, part of the Spratly Islands, 480km (298 miles) west of the Philippines’ coastline dubbing it an “illegal invasion”.

Today, just days after US and Philippines military forces completed a military exercise in the South China Sea at Pag-asa (Thitu) Island, Chinese fishing vessels have been seen swarming into areas of the Spratly’s where they have not been seen before.

Chinese fishing boats not fishing

In a report accompanying satellite images released by US-based think tank the Asia Maritime Transparency Initiative-Center for Strategic and International Studies (Amti-CSIS), it said “In almost every instance, the vessels are riding at anchor, many in large clusters, and without fishing gear in the water”.

Some 23 Chinese fishing and marine vessels were seen as close as one kilometre off Kota Island (Loaita Island) Loaita Cay (Panata Island*), about 24 km south of Pag-asa (Thitu) Island, the report said.

While hardly a ‘swarm’, the report notes that the number of Chinese fishing and other vessels in the area had steadily increased from just one 50-meter Chinese fishing trawler near Kota on March 12.

According to Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) chief-of-staff General Benjamin Madrigal Jr, more than 200 Chinese vessels have been circling Pag-asa Island since January this year.

Up until this announcement on Saturday and Sunday the Philippines government has staunchly denied ceding any territory to China. Earlier this month President Duterte threatened to order Filipino soldiers “to prepare for a suicide mission” to defend Pag-asa Shoal.


Feature photo Amti-CSIS



  • Chinese vessels enter 2 more PH islands’ waters (Philippine Daily Inquirer)
  • Panelo to Del Rosario: Duterte admin fixing your mess after PHL lost Scarborough to China (GMA News Online)
  • Still Under Pressure: Manila Versus the Militia (AMTI-CSIS)
  • Foul-mouthed Duterte: goodbye POTUS, hello Huangyan Island (AEC News Today)


*Panata has been erroneously called Lankiam Cay in Philippine maps


The following two tabs change content below.

John Le Fevre

Thailand editor at AEC News Today

John is an Australian national with more than 40 years experience as a journalist, photographer, videographer, and copy editor.

He has spent extensive periods of time working in Africa and throughout Southeast Asia, with stints in the Middle East, the USA, and England.

He has covered major world events including Operation Desert Shield/ Storm, the 1991 pillage in Zaire, the 1994 Rwanda genocide, the 1999 East Timor independence unrest, the 2004 Asian tsunami, and the 2009, 2010, and 2014 Bangkok political protests.

In 1995 he was a Walkley Award finalist, the highest awards in Australian journalism, for his coverage of the 1995 Zaire (now Democratic Republic of Congo) Ebola outbreak.

Prior to AEC News Today he was the deputy editor and Thailand and Greater Mekong Sub-region editor for The Establishment Post, predecessor of Asean Today.

In the mid-80s and early 90s he owned JLF Promotions, the largest above and below the line marketing and PR firm servicing the high-technology industry in Australia. It was sold in 1995.

Support independent media by sharing using these tools. Do not steal our content

Make a comment

Your email address will not be published.